| LNAME | FNAME | MI | TITLE | YEARS | ORDAINED FROM | YEAR |
| Altrui | Ronald | P. | Parochial Vicar | 1996-1998 | Dunwoodie | 1981 |
| Aylward | Michael | V. | Pastor | 1910-1921 | Troy | 1884 |
| Bergan | Gerald | I. | Assistant | 1894-1894 | ||
| Bisignano | Joseph | F. | Administrator | 10/1996-1/1997 | Dunwoodie | 1981 |
| Bisignano | Joseph | F. | Administrator | 2000-2003 | Dunwoodie | 1981 |
| Boylan | John | N. | Assistant | 1906-1909 | Dunwoodie | 1906 |
| Briody | John | H. | Pastor | 1900-1910 | Troy | 1887 |
| Burke | William | M. | Assistant | 1913-1915 | Dunwoodie | 1913 |
| Canary | Andrew | J. | guest fill-in | 1878-1878 | ||
| Carlin | John | A. | Assistant | 1942-1944 | Dunwoodie | 1939 |
| Cassidy | James | A. | Pastor | 1934-1953 | Dunwoodie | 1912 |
| Conlan | James | S. | Assistant | 1953-1955 | Dunwoodie | 1953 |
| Coyle | James | Pastor | 1860-1867 | Fordham | 1854 | |
| Defina | Thomas | Assistant | 1875-1876 | |||
| Dougherty | Thomas | B. | Pastor | 1921-1934 | Lateran | 1906 |
| Drew | William | B. | Assistant | 1935-1941 | Dunwoodie | 1935 |
| Drew | William | B. | Assistant | 1944-1967 | Dunwoodie | 1935 |
| Duffy | William | B. | Assistant | 1933-1934 | Dunwoodie | 1917 |
| Farrell | Christopher | O. | Pastor | 1867-1871 | Fordham | 1860 |
| Fennessey | Denis | A. | Assistant | 1915-1919 | Dunwoodie | 1915 |
| Foley | Joseph | A. | Assistant | 1897-1898 | Dunwoodie | 1897 |
| Geissler | Robert | J. | Assistant | 1955-1976 | Dunwoodie | 1947 |
| Golden | Victor | F.X. | Assistant | 1941-1941 | Dunwoodie | 1941 |
| Harper | Francis | X. | Assistant | 1934-1935 | Dunwoodie | 1929 |
| Henry | John | C. | Pastor | 1877-1884 | Troy | 1869 |
| Kelly | Terence | F. | Assistant | 1878-1880 | Montreal | 1878 |
| Kelly | Terence | F. | Pastor | 1890-1900 | Montreal | 1878 |
| Larkin | John | P. | Pastor | 1982-1983 | Dunwoodie | 1944 |
| Leo | A. Rocco | Assistant | 1989-1989 | Dunwoodie | 1985 | |
| Luedke | Richard | A. | Pastor | 1964-1982 | Dunwoodie | 1934 |
| Lynch | John | J. | Parochial Vicar | 1990-1996 | Dunwoodie | 1965 |
| Mackey | Martin | G. | Assistant | 1935-1941 | Dunwoodie | 1924 |
| Martin | Edward | R. | Assistant | 1921-1925 | Dunwoodie | 1921 |
| McCabe | Hugh | J. | Assistant | 1890-1890 | ||
| McCourt | Peter | Pastor | 1871-1876 | Troy | 1868 | |
| McDonnell | J. | 1866-1867 | ||||
| McGrath | John | J. | Assistant | 1880-1885 | Bonaventure | |
| McGuire | Michael | A. | Assistant | 1925-1932 | Dunwoodie | 1925 |
| McMenamin | Stephen | A. | Assistant | 1919-1920 | Dunwodie | 1920 |
| McNamee | J. | J. | Administrator | 1871-1871 | ||
| McSwiggan | Michael | J. | Pastor | 1884-1890 | ||
| Moran | Thomas | J. | Assistant | 1948-1953 | Dunwoodie | 1948 |
| Moran | Thomas | J. | Pastor | 1983-1984 | Dunwoodie | 1948 |
| Moylan | John | J. | Assistant | 1904-1905 | Dunwoodie | 1904 |
| Murphy | Michael | J. | Assistant | 1920-1921 | Dunwoodie | 1920 |
| Newman | Michael | W. | Administrator | 1876-1877 | ||
| Nicholas | John | M. | Pastor | 1953-1959 | Dunwoodie | 1925 |
| Obba | Thaddeus | O. | Parochial Vicar | 1998-2002 | Nigeria | |
| Orson | Lawrence | M. | Administrator | 1984-1985 | Dunwoodie | 1953 |
| Parker | Moses | E. | Assistant | 1886-1890 | ||
| Phillips | Thomas | J. | Assistant | 1942-1942 | Dunwoodie | 1942 |
| Plover | Edward | M. | Assistant | 1932-1934 | Rome | 1931 |
| Poulin | Donald | J. | Pastor | 1985-1996 | Dunwoodie | 1966 |
| Power | James | J. | Assistant | 1905-1906 | ||
| Sansone | Vincent | S. | Assistant | 1898-1900 | ||
| Schwartz | Francis | X. | Assistant | 1934-1935 | Innsbruck | 1928 |
| Sheehan | Denis | Pastor | 1853-1860 | |||
| Stanford | Joseph | V. | Assistant | 1909-1913 | Dunwoodie | 1909 |
| Sweeney | William | E. | Assistant | 1926-1933 | Dunwoodie | 1926 |
| Takyia | Andrew | Kwame | Summer help | 1997, 1998 | Ghana | |
| Tierney | Thaddeus | W. | Assistant | 1901-1904 | Dunwoodie | 1901 |
| Tully | James | F. | Pastor | 1959-1964 | Dunwoodie | 1929 |
| Vitanza | Joseph | A. | Assistant | 1941-1944 | Dunwoodie | 1930 |
| Wallace | Vincent | A. | Assistant | 1976-1990 | Dunwoodie | 1941 |
| Walsh | Andrew | J. | Administrator | 1997-2000 | Dunwoodie | 1966 |
| Welch | Michael | J. | Assistant | 1885-1886 | ||
| White | James | A. | Assistant | 1890-1899 | ||
| Bonaventure = St. Bonaventure Seminary, Allegany, NY | ||||||
| Dunwoodie = St. Joseph Seminary, Dunwoodie, Yonkers, NY | ||||||
| Fordham = St. John's College, Fordham, NY | ||||||
| Innsbruck = Collegium Canisianium, Innsbruck, Austria | ||||||
| Lateran = St. John Lateran, Rome, Italy | ||||||
| Montreal = | ||||||
| Rome = North American College, Rome, Italy | ||||||
| Troy = St. Joseph's Seminary, Troy, NY | ||||||
| Louvain - Belgium | ||||||
| Additional priests whose names appear in the Baptismal Register of St. Joachim’s, but on whom we have no additional information are: Rev. John Morris (1890), Rev. D.J. O'Keefe (1890), Rev. John J. Morse (1890). They may have helped out during Fr. McSwiggan’s illness and death before Fr. Kelly became pastor in December 1890. | ||||||